Issues #6193: sRpN5 does not test for the case where URCBs are association based (non-indexed). - Server - UCAIug Issue Tracking System

Issues #6193

sRpN5 does not test for the case where URCBs are association based (non-indexed).

Added by IEC 61850 TPWG almost 2 years ago. Updated 9 months ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

Normal

Assignee:

Richard Schimmel

Due date:

01/24/2023

Discuss in Upcoming Meeting:

Clause Reference:

61850 Standard:

Triggering Tissue:

Final Decision:

Initial Test Document:

Ed2 TP2.0.6 and Ed2Amd1 TP1.2

Updated Test Document:

TP1.3

Test Case ID:

Closed Reason:

--Not Set---

Triggering Tissue 2:

Triggering Tissue 3:

Description

the goal of the test is that an URCB instance is “protected” and can’t be changed by another client. When URCBs are non-indexed (association based) such protection is evident, but there should be a test case to be sure that two clients get their own URCB instance.
This applies to both edition 2 and edition 2.1

Files

Solution to redmine 6193 sRpN5.docx	Solution to redmine 6193 sRpN5.docx	21.3 KB		Richard Schimmel, 11/29/2022 09:35 AM
Solution to redmine 6193 sRpN5 (Jan24).docx	Solution to redmine 6193 sRpN5 (Jan24).docx	21.2 KB		Richard Schimmel, 01/24/2023 09:48 AM

Updated by Richard Schimmel almost 2 years ago

File Solution to redmine 6193 sRpN5.docx Solution to redmine 6193 sRpN5.docx added
Initial Test Document set to Ed2 TP2.0.6 and Ed2Amd1 TP1.2

Added solution

Updated by Thierry Dufaure almost 2 years ago

I agree with the proposal of Richard.
I recommend nevertheless the wording:
when (SCL ReportControl indexed=true or SCL ReportControl indexed is not present) and response+ when SCL indexed=false

Updated by IEC 61850 TPWG almost 2 years ago

Due date changed from 01/10/2023 to 01/24/2023
Assignee changed from Richard Schimmel to Thierry Dufaure

Thierry is to investigate further whether indexed="false" is allowed with only one instance.

Updated by Thierry Dufaure almost 2 years ago

indexed="false" is allowed with max="1".
Propose wording:
DUT sends SetURCBValues response+ when (SCL indexed=false and max > 1), otherwise DUT sends SetURCBValues response- with data access error = temporarily-unavailable.