Project

General

Profile

CIM Issues #6811

Clean up Equivalent modelling descriptions and classnames

Added by Todd Viegut 5 months ago. Updated 5 days ago.

Status:
Closed
Priority:
Normal
Author/Contact Info:
Todd Viegut
Base Release:
CIM18
Solution to be Applied To:
CIM18v14
Solution Version:
CIM18v14
Solution Applied By:
Chavdar Ivanov
Completion Date:
11/18/2024
CIM Keywords:
61970-Equivalents
Breaking Change:
Yes
Breaking Change Description:
Class names will be changed
CIM Impacted Groups:
WG13
Requestor:
Standard(s):

IEC61970-301

Version:
Clause:
Sub-Clause:
Paragraph:
Table:
Originally Closed in Version:
Origination Date:
Origination ID:
Originally Assigned To:

Description

During hybrid meetings in Tokyo on 13-Jun-2024 we reviewed the Equivalent* classes and attributes as it pertains to the 301. We identified deficiencies in the existing modelling and changes from original modelling updates that were done as part of https://redmine.ucaiug.org/issues/5047.


Files


Proposed Solution

Proposed description changes are outlined here:

CHANGE #1 : Current EquivalentInjection description changes:

FROM: "This class represents equivalent injections (generation or load). Voltage regulation is allowed only at the point of connection. Using EquivalentInjection to model a distribution network equivalent is recommended practice instead of using ExternalNetworkInjection-s if it is not necessary that the equivalent contains detailed information representing a short circuit equivalent according to IEC 60909 which is relevant for short circuit studies."

TO: "This class represents networks that have been equivalized using either the ward or extended ward method. "

Existing class description updates (stated here for informational purposes...will not be changed):

WardEquivelent should be: "A ward equivalent is a combination of an impedance load and a PQ load."

ExtendedWardEquivalent should be: "An extended ward equivalent is a combination of an impedance load, a PQ load and as voltage source with an internal impedance."

CHANGE #2 : ExternalNetworkInjection description changes:

FROM: "This class represents the external network and is used for IEC 60909 calculations. It is only used if EquivalentInjection cannot provide the details required by IEC 60909 on short circuit equivalent of an external network."

TO: ??? This is an open TODO as part of this issue.

CHANGE #3 : Create new UML diagrams in the UML that can be generated as part of the 301. This potentially involves cleanup of existing diagrams (for WardEquivalent & ExtendedWardEquivalent) as well as the requirements to include the electrical diagrams.


Decision

Minneapolis meeting - Sep 2024
Richard will upload v3 of the document
AI Chavdar to apply the changes and close the ticket


Release Notes

Changed description of classes according to v3 of the attached document
Changes are applied to:
ExternalNetworkInjection and attributes ikSecond, maxInitialSymShCCurrent, maxQ, maxR0ToX0Ratio, maxR1ToX1Ratio,maxZ0ToZ1Ratio , minInitialSymShCCurrent, minQ, minR0ToX0Ratio, minR1ToX1Ratio, voltageFactor, minZ0ToZ1Ratio

EquivalentInjection and the attributes: maxQ, minQ,
ExtendedWardEquivalent - attributes r, r0, r2, x, x0, x2.

#1

Updated by Chavdar Ivanov 3 months ago

  • Status changed from New to Open
#2

Updated by Richard de Groot 2 months ago

In response to TODO for CHANGE #2. Attached document provides:
  • proposal for definition of class ExternalNetworkInjection,
  • proposals for definition of selected attributes of class ExternalNetworkInjection to correct imprecisions,
  • proposal for minor change to definition of EquivalentInjection, to harmonise with ExternalNetworkInjection.
#3

Updated by Richard de Groot 2 months ago

Request by Martin Miller to expand with references to definitions. And closer study showed previous version was not very good. This one is better.

In response to TODO for CHANGE #2. Attached document provides proposal for:
  • new definition of class ExternalNetworkInjection,
  • corrected and expanded definitions for selected attributes of class ExternalNetworkInjection,
  • in spite of CHANGE #1 improvement for definition of EquivalentInjection,
  • corrected definitions for selected attributes of class EquivalentInjection.
#4

Updated by Richard de Groot 2 months ago

During hybrid meeting in Minneapolis on 20 September agreed that references to IEC60909-0 for definitions will be including clause number and version. Revised document to V3.

#5

Updated by Chavdar Ivanov 5 days ago

  • Status changed from Open to In Progress
  • Completion Date set to 11/18/2024
  • Decision updated (diff)
  • Release Notes updated (diff)
#6

Updated by Chavdar Ivanov 5 days ago

  • Status changed from In Progress to Closed
  • Solution to be Applied To changed from CIM18 to CIM18v14
  • Solution Version set to CIM18v14
  • Solution Applied By set to Chavdar Ivanov
  • CIM Impacted Groups WG13 added
  • CIM Impacted Groups deleted (None)

Also available in: Atom PDF