CIM Issues #5047: Clarifications on equivalents, e.g., EquivalentInjection, ExternalNetworkInjections and the aggregate attribute - WG13 Issues - UCAIug Issue Tracking System

CIM Issues #5047

Clarifications on equivalents, e.g., EquivalentInjection, ExternalNetworkInjections and the aggregate attribute

Added by Herbert Falk about 3 years ago. Updated almost 2 years ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

Normal

Author/Contact Info:

Todd Viegut

Base Release:

CIM17

Solution to be Applied To:

CIM18v03

Solution Version:

CIM18v03

Solution Applied By:

Chavdar Ivanov

Completion Date:

02/11/2023

CIM Keywords:

61970-Equivalents

Breaking Change:

Breaking Change Description:

CIM Impacted Groups:

WG13

Requestor:

Standard(s):

61970-301

Version:

7.1

Clause:

Equivalents

Sub-Clause:

Paragraph:

Table:

Originally Closed in Version:

Origination Date:

01/14/2020

Origination ID:

13_301

Originally Assigned To:

Description

Per CDV country comments CH_86 for 301 Ed7:

Many TSOs use external network injections which can have distant regulation for modelling distribution network, although it is stated that the class is used for IEC 60909 calculations. It is necessary to specify in which use cases it is suggested to use EquivalentInjection and in which cases ExternalNetworkInjection.

Proposed Solution

Update the descriptions to clarify the usage. Perhaps EquivalentInjections should be used for distribution network equivalenting and not ExternalNetworkInjections, but this needs to be clarified.

Clarifications to be applied in CIM18 because there are multiple uses currently in implementations. Must be discussed with distribution experts. The description should go into the 600 specs as well.

Assign to Energy Model Requirements Subgroup
See additional information:
https://github.com/CIMug-org/WG13InformationModel/issues/5

Update: Feb 2023 by Chavdar
452 and 600 use this constraint
• C:452:EQ:EquivalenInjection:instance
Using EquivalentInjection to model a distribution network equivalent is recommended practice instead of using ExternalNetworkInjection-s.

Decision

14-Jan-2020 Decision to apply the proposed resolution when revving to CIM18

Release Notes

- Added the following clarification to the EquivalentInjection description

Using EquivalentInjection to model a distribution network equivalent is recommended practice instead of using ExternalNetworkInjection-s if it is not necessary that the equivalent contains detailed information representing a short circuit equivalent according to IEC 60909 which is relevant for short circuit studies.

- Added the following clarification to the ExternalNetworkInjection description
It is only used if EquivalentInjection cannot provide the details required by IEC 60909 on short circuit equivalent of an external network.

- Modeified the following statement in the Equipment.aggregate to include ExternalNetworkInjection. The revised version is:
The attribute is not used for EquivalentBranch, EquivalentShunt, EquivalentInjection and ExternalNetworkInjection.

- Deleted the folling constraint from 452
• C:452:EQ:EquivalenInjection:instance
Using EquivalentInjection to model a distribution network equivalent is recommended practice instead of using ExternalNetworkInjection-s.

Updated by Eric Stephan about 3 years ago

Subject changed from Per CDV country comments CH_86 for 301 Ed7: Many TSOs use to Per CDV country comments CH_86 for 301 Ed7:Many TSOs use
Proposed Solution updated (diff)
Decision updated (diff)

Updated by Svein Olsen about 3 years ago

Subject changed from Per CDV country comments CH_86 for 301 Ed7:Many TSOs use to Equivalent CDV CH_86 for 301 Ed7
Description updated (diff)
Standard(s) set to 61970-301
Version set to 7.1
Clause set to Equivalents
Decision updated (diff)

Updated by Eric Stephan almost 3 years ago

Proposed Solution updated (diff)
Decision updated (diff)
CIM Keywords 61970-Equivalents added

Updated by Yang Feng over 2 years ago

Subject changed from Equivalent CDV CH_86 for 301 Ed7 to Clarifications on equivalents, e.g., EquivalentInjection, ExternalNetworkInjections and the aggregate attribute