Issues #6279: sSBOns8 - Test and Check in Cancel after Select request - Server - UCAIug Issue Tracking System

Issues #6279

sSBOns8 - Test and Check in Cancel after Select request

Added by Hua Qin over 1 year ago. Updated 9 months ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

Normal

Assignee:

Richard Schimmel

Due date:

05/30/2023

Discuss in Upcoming Meeting:

Clause Reference:

61850 Standard:

Triggering Tissue:

Final Decision:

Initial Test Document:

TP1.2

Updated Test Document:

TP1.3

Test Case ID:

sSBOns8

Closed Reason:

Test Procedure Update

Triggering Tissue 2:

Triggering Tissue 3:

Description

There is no way to check the consistency between Select and Cancel.
But as a normal control service, it should be subject to the normal checks, such as Test and Check in this test case.
Thus, DUT may give a Cancel response- on step h/j.

I understand that this test case is introduced because of TISUSE 1703.
Tissue 1703 comments talks about there is no way to check the consistency in SBOns situation.
The last comment also says "for the case of normal security a cancel request has to carry service parameters that have no meaning."
Tissue 1703 suggests that update will be added into part 7-2 amend 1.

In part 7-2 ED2 Amend 1, I do not find anywhere mentioning it.

But in part 8-1 20.7.4 says "the service parameter consistency check of the Cancel request can not be excecuted in case the Cancel request is used after a Select request, as long as no Operate / TimeActivatedOperate request was received.Cancel response+ "

Again this part talks about no way to check the consistency.

Files

Solution to redmine 6188 and 6279 sSBOns8.docx

22.8 KB

Richard Schimmel, 05/16/2023 09:10 AM

Updated by IEC 61850 TPWG over 1 year ago

Due date set to 03/21/2023
Status changed from New to In Progress
Assignee set to Richard Schimmel

Updated by IEC 61850 TPWG over 1 year ago

Due date changed from 03/21/2023 to 05/02/2023

Updated by Richard Schimmel over 1 year ago

What is the proposed solution? Allow Cancel response- on Cancel.Check=00/11 (step h and j)? If both Cancel+ and Cancel- are allowed we just skip step h and j. (See also #6188 in which we removed the Cancel.orCat)