Bug #449
GSE MaxTime and MinTime parameters are optional with no default value
Added by Herbert Falk about 3 years ago.
Updated about 2 years ago.
Category:
Standard clarification required
TF Unique ID:
6 # IOP_2013
WG10 Proposal:
According to Cathedral City meeting (ref. to UFTF-CathedralMOM20160219) this issue is closed.
Discuss in Upcoming Meeting:
No
Short Proposal:
Suggest that WG10 defines default behavior if these values are missing or declare them as mandatory for ED.2.
Description
An SCL file was attempted to be imported that had TMAX and TMIN missing. The expected behavior for this case is not specified. And the file import was rejected.
61850-6 defines TMAX and TMIN as optional in order to provide backward compatibility with ED.1 schema. However, in ED.2 the fact that these are needed to control the expected behavior creates a need to define the default behavior or to develop a ED.2 profile that can be applied in addition to the XSD for validation.
Submit the concept of profiling to WG10
- Priority changed from Normal to High
- Subject changed from An SCL file was attempted to be imported that had TMAX and TMIN missing. The expected behavior for this case is not specified. A to GSE MaxTime and MinTime parameters are optional with no default value
- Status changed from New to Feedback
- Standard(s) set to IEC 61850-6
- Discuss in Upcoming Meeting set to No
Checking done.
Check if it is really solved because I do not see any solution in part 6 ed2 o 8-1
- Discuss in Upcoming Meeting changed from No to Yes
- Status changed from Feedback to Triage
IEC 61850-8-1 Ed2.1 as specified that minTime and maxTime are mandatory for a fully configured GSEControl.
(Text below table 163).
As well it is stated that:
"Configuration compliant with previous version of the standard may not contained the configured elements scl.tGSE.MinTime and scl.tGSE.MaxTime. It is a local issue of the publisher to use default values in that case. "
- Status changed from Triage to Closed
- Discuss in Upcoming Meeting changed from Yes to No
- Proposal descriptions updated (diff)
- To discuss in WG10 set to No
Also available in: Atom
PDF