Issues #669
T1681 - LActTm representation is not actual (sSg13, sSg14)
Description
Issue
The explanation for LActTm is as follows:
"Time when the last service SelectActiveSG has been processed successfully"
This means that updating this attribute is only related to the SelectActSG service.
However, in fact, switching of setting group can also occur in ways that are outside of this standard (for example., using a switch connected to the digital inputs). Obviously, in such cases, the ActSG attribute should also change, but the LActTm timestamp will remain the same, continuing representing a time of the last SelectActiveSG service result.
I think this attribute would be more useful from a practical point of view if it represents the actual switching time of the active setting group.
Proposal
Expand the explanation so that LActTm should change whenever the ActSG attribute actually changes.
Files
Subtasks
Updated by Bruce Muschlitz over 3 years ago
- File TestProcedure_sSg13.docx TestProcedure_sSg13.docx added
- Final Decision changed from Modify test to match Tissue 1681: to Modify test to match Tissue 1681 resolution
- Initial Test Document set to http://www.ucaiug.org/org/TechnicalO/Testing/UCAIug%20Testing%20Quality%20Assurance%20Program/Current%20IEC%2061850%20Edition%202%20Testing%20Procedures/UCATestProceduresServer61850-8-1Ed2Amd1_Rev1p0.pdf
- Test Case ID set to sSg13
Updated by Richard Schimmel over 3 years ago
- Status changed from New to In Progress
TPWG: Please look at sSg3 which already verifies Last activation time. We disagree to add a new testcase
Updated by Bruce Muschlitz over 3 years ago
sSg3 is test when Client initiates a change to ActSG. sSg13 is test when server spontaneously changes ActSG without a request from the client.
Reason for TISSUE is now "standard is not clear that spontaneous changes to ActSG should result in new value of LActTm" (note that this is not reflected in the title of the TISSUE but first appears in the TISSUE 20200617).
Therefore sSG13 is needed (and agreed by WG10 to be inserted into the test procedures).
Updated by Richard Schimmel over 3 years ago
added file with proposed solution
Updated by Richard Schimmel about 3 years ago
- File Solution to redmine_669_sSg13_20210914.docx Solution to redmine_669_sSg13_20210914.docx added
- Subject changed from T1681 - LActTm representation is not actual to T1681 - LActTm representation is not actual (sSg13, sSg14)
- Test Case ID changed from sSg13 (sSg3) to sSg13 and sSg14
Added sSg14 to the solution to change a setting in the active setting group; Updated sSg13 a bit (setting group)
Updated by Richard Schimmel about 3 years ago
- File Solution to redmine_669_sSg13_20210921.docx Solution to redmine_669_sSg13_20210921.docx added
- Status changed from In Progress to Resolved
TPWG agreement to resolve after adding a reference to tissue 1681 in both test procedures. It was noted that the TISSUE database proposal is an older version (no further action required)
Updated by Bruce Muschlitz over 2 years ago
- Discuss in Upcoming Meeting changed from Yes to No
- Updated Test Document set to Server Ed2.1 TP1.2
- Closed Reason Test Procedure Update added
- Closed Reason deleted (
--Not Set---)