Issues #5328: sFt2ab issues with "directory" files - Server - UCAIug Issue Tracking System

Issues #5328

sFt2ab issues with "directory" files

Added by Bruce Muschlitz 11 months ago. Updated 8 months ago.

Status:

Resolved

Priority:

Normal

Assignee:

Due date:

Discuss in Upcoming Meeting:

Clause Reference:

61850 Standard:

8-1

Triggering Tissue:

Final Decision:

Initial Test Document:

Updated Test Document:

Server Ed2.0 TP2.0.7 and Server Ed2.1...

Test Case ID:

Closed Reason:

Test Procedure Update

Triggering Tissue 2:

Triggering Tissue 3:

Description

61850 allows "filename" to be a string terminated by a delimiter. This is interpreted as the name of a directory instead of a file.
1. sFt2ab step 1 requires that the test system issue a GetFile for each entry in the GetServerDirectory(FILE) response but it does not make sense to perform this request on a directory and it also makes no sense to require a positive response from the DUT in this case
2. sFt2ab step 2 requires that the test system issue a GetFileAttributeValues for each entry in the GetServerDirectory(FILE) response but it does not make sense to perform this request on a directory and it also makes no sense to require a positive response from the DUT in this case

The proposed solution is to clarify that only non-directory requests be issued in each step of the test description
Proposed solution attached with blue text to be inserted.

Files

sFt2ab.docx	sFt2ab.docx	13.6 KB		Bruce Muschlitz, 03/22/2022 03:45 PM
sFt2ab_20220501.docx	sFt2ab_20220501.docx	14.6 KB		Bruce Muschlitz, 05/01/2022 06:22 PM

Updated by Thierry Dufaure 10 months ago

I think that moving the "which does not specify a file directory next to the FileName is easier to read:

For each File Name (which does not specify a file directory) in the listOfDirectoryEntry as returned by GetServerDirectory(FILE) using an empty file specification :

Alternative: do not extend the text but add a note to the test case:
Note: for File Name representing files and not file directory.

Updated by Bruce Muschlitz 10 months ago

Agree that the wording could be more clear.
Suggest for entire test description before item 1:
Simulator performs a GetServerDirectory(FILE) using an empty file specification and collects the response listOfDirectoryEntry. For each response which does not specify a file directory (i.e. a response which is not terminated with a file delimiter), perform the following steps.