Issues #5328: sFt2ab issues with "directory" files - Server - UCAIug Issue Tracking System

Issues #5328

sFt2ab issues with "directory" files

Added by Bruce Muschlitz over 2 years ago. Updated 9 months ago.

Status:

Closed

Priority:

Normal

Assignee:

Due date:

Discuss in Upcoming Meeting:

Clause Reference:

61850 Standard:

8-1

Triggering Tissue:

Final Decision:

Initial Test Document:

Updated Test Document:

Server Ed2.0 TP2.0.7 and Server Ed2.1...

Test Case ID:

Closed Reason:

Test Procedure Update

Triggering Tissue 2:

Triggering Tissue 3:

Description

61850 allows "filename" to be a string terminated by a delimiter. This is interpreted as the name of a directory instead of a file.
1. sFt2ab step 1 requires that the test system issue a GetFile for each entry in the GetServerDirectory(FILE) response but it does not make sense to perform this request on a directory and it also makes no sense to require a positive response from the DUT in this case
2. sFt2ab step 2 requires that the test system issue a GetFileAttributeValues for each entry in the GetServerDirectory(FILE) response but it does not make sense to perform this request on a directory and it also makes no sense to require a positive response from the DUT in this case

The proposed solution is to clarify that only non-directory requests be issued in each step of the test description
Proposed solution attached with blue text to be inserted.

Files

sFt2ab.docx	sFt2ab.docx	13.6 KB		Bruce Muschlitz, 03/22/2022 03:45 PM
sFt2ab_20220501.docx	sFt2ab_20220501.docx	14.6 KB		Bruce Muschlitz, 05/01/2022 06:22 PM

Updated by Thierry Dufaure over 2 years ago

I think that moving the "which does not specify a file directory next to the FileName is easier to read:

For each File Name (which does not specify a file directory) in the listOfDirectoryEntry as returned by GetServerDirectory(FILE) using an empty file specification :

Alternative: do not extend the text but add a note to the test case:
Note: for File Name representing files and not file directory.

Updated by Bruce Muschlitz over 2 years ago

Agree that the wording could be more clear.
Suggest for entire test description before item 1:
Simulator performs a GetServerDirectory(FILE) using an empty file specification and collects the response listOfDirectoryEntry. For each response which does not specify a file directory (i.e. a response which is not terminated with a file delimiter), perform the following steps.