Project

General

Profile

Issues #5319

T1782 sCtl7 addcause "inconsistent-parameters" when check=00 not-supported

Added by Richard Schimmel 7 months ago. Updated about 2 months ago.

Status:
In Progress
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
-
Due date:
10/04/2022 (Due in 5 days)
Discuss in Upcoming Meeting:
No
Clause Reference:
61850 Standard:
Triggering Tissue:
Final Decision:
Initial Test Document:
Updated Test Document:
Test Case ID:
sCtl7
Closed Reason:
Test Procedure Update
Triggering Tissue 2:
Triggering Tissue 3:

Description

The current Ed2 and Amd1 sCtl7 test procedure allows to ignore the check=00 and still perform the interlock/synchro check. Currently the TP allow AddCause not-supported and blocked-by-interlocking. The Tissue is very clear and requires "inconsistent-parameters".

Proposal are:
- Amd1 to only allow "inconsistent-parameters"
- Ed2 allow not-supported, blocked-by-interlocking and inconsistent-parameters.


Files

sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220224docx.docx sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220224docx.docx 17.7 KB Bruce Muschlitz, 02/24/2022 02:06 PM
sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220306.docx sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220306.docx 17.6 KB Bruce Muschlitz, 03/06/2022 07:25 PM
sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220308.docx sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220308.docx 17.7 KB Bruce Muschlitz, 03/08/2022 11:23 AM
#1

Updated by Richard Schimmel 7 months ago

  • Test Case ID set to sCtl7

Tissue 1782 is not part of the batch of tissues 57_2445_INF and should (shall) not be implemented in TP2.0.6 and TP1.2

#2

Updated by Bruce Muschlitz 7 months ago

Propose to split step 2 into 2 conditional steps (2 and 3) depending upon whether server supports or refuses Check bypass (or is configurable for both).
Attached revision shows blue text to add or strikethrough blue text to delete for the Ed2.0 test procedures. PIXIT CT8 is also modified.
For Ed2.1 test procedures, the attached text is also used except that the text ["Not-supported" or] is removed from expected result step 2 and Ct8 PIXIT entry.

#3

Updated by Bruce Muschlitz 7 months ago

Step 3 was incorrect. If Client request interlock byoass and DUT specifies that it allows interlock bypass then DUT should respond positively and NOT with an error.
sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220306 is attached

#4

Updated by Richard Schimmel 7 months ago

  • Status changed from New to In Progress
#5

Updated by Bruce Muschlitz 7 months ago

As agreed during TPWG meeting 08-March-2022, removed from Expected result 2 ability of DUT to respond positively.
Test procedure sCtl7_proposal_Ed2p1_20220308.docx atached.
Also note that attached test procedure is for Ed2.0 and the corresponding Ed2.1 procedure is same except Expected result step 2 omits [“Not-supported” or ] in 5 places

#6

Updated by Thierry Dufaure 6 months ago

There is a discrepancy between the testing procedure and the tissue resolution.
Old testing procedures were allowing "not-supported" or "blocked-by-interlocking".
Tissue resolution specifies only "inconsistent-parameters"
New testing procedures is allowing "inconsistent-parameters" OR "not-supported" or "blocked-by-interlocking".

#7

Updated by Joel Greene 6 months ago

  • Status changed from Resolved to In Progress
#8

Updated by Thierry Dufaure 6 months ago

During the Conformance Test Verification stage, the editofrs discussed the discrepancy between the testing procedure and and the tissue resolution.

Old testing procedures were allowing "not-supported" or "blocked-by-interlocking".

Tissue resolution specifies only "inconsistent-parameters"

New testing procedures is allowing "inconsistent-parameters" OR "not-supported" or "blocked-by-interlocking".

The tissue resolution under drafting propose now the usage of addCause "Not-supported".
How can a test procedure overwrite the tissue resolution? I.e. if the resolution propses 1 addCause, how can it end in the test procedure as 3 addCauses?

#9

Updated by Bruce Muschlitz 4 months ago

  • Discuss in Upcoming Meeting changed from Yes to No
#10

Updated by Joel Greene 2 months ago

  • Due date set to 08/09/2022

TISSUE still in progress.

#11

Updated by IEC 61850 TPWG about 2 months ago

  • Due date changed from 08/09/2022 to 10/04/2022

Also available in: Atom PDF