CIM Issues #5005
GroundDisconnector examples. The intended use of GroundDisconnector
61970-301
Description
GroundDisconnector examples
The intended use of GroundDisconnector is unclear. Describe the containment in figure 19 in the 301 and change "GroundSwitch" to "GroundDisconnecter" as "GroundSwitch" do not exist in the UML.
Files
Proposed Solution
301 document correction.
Assign to Physical Devices Subgroup
Decision
This may have already been corrected. Chavdar to check.
11-Sep-2024 TF13 weekly call:
I have attached a GroundDisconnector examples document produced jointly by Richard and Svein. This to be discussed during next week's Fall Joint TF Hybrid meetings in Minneapolis.
17-Sep-2024: TF13 Minneapolis meeting
Agreement:
- Deprecate GroundDisconnector
- Change 301 to refer to Disconnector between Phase N
- Add EarthingSwitch as subclass of Switch. Description “a mechanical switching device for earthing parts of a circuit, capable of withstanding for a specified time currents under abnormal conditions such as those of short circuit, but not required to carry current under normal conditions of the circuit
Note 1 to entry: An earthing switch may have a short-circuit making capacity.
”
- Change the description of Disconnector from
“A manually operated or motor operated mechanical switching device used for changing the connections in a circuit, or for isolating a circuit or equipment from a source of power. It is required to open or close circuits when negligible current is broken or made.”
To
“ mechanical switching device which provides, in the open position, an isolating distance in accordance with specified requirements
Note 1 to entry: A disconnector is capable of opening and closing a circuit when either negligible current is broken or made, or when no significant change in the voltage across the terminals of each of the poles of the disconnector occurs. It is also capable of carrying currents under normal circuit conditions and carrying for a specified time currents under abnormal conditions such as those of short circuit.”
- EarthingSwitch is single terminal device which implicitly connects to the earth
- Revise 301 to explain how Ground is used. The EarthingSwitch and Ground are not related. They serve different purpose
Profile Decisions (452/456):
Decision was to deprecate GroundDisconnector
Release Notes
The following changes are applied in 301/UML
- added stereotype deprecated to GroundDisconnector
- modified description of Disconnector
- added EarthingSwitch
- 301 document template is updated
The following changes are applied in 452 - EQ
- added stereotype deprecated to GroundDisconnector
- added EarthingSwitch
The following changes are applied in 456 - SSH
- added stereotype deprecated to GroundDisconnector
- added EarthingSwitch
Updated by Eric Stephan about 3 years ago
- Subject changed from GroundDisconnector examples The intended use of GroundDisco to GroundDisconnector examplesThe intended use of GroundDisco
- Decision updated (diff)
Updated by Eric Stephan almost 3 years ago
Updated by Eric Stephan about 2 years ago
- Status changed from Open to In Progress
- Priority changed from Normal to High
- Standard(s) set to 61970-301
- Decision updated (diff)
- Originally Assigned To set to Chavdar Ivanof
Updated by Eric Stephan about 2 years ago
Updated by Todd Viegut over 1 year ago
Notes from the 12-Apr-2023 UTF13 weekly call:
The GroundDisconnector is now a 2 terminal device - the 301 template was updated in 2016 Ed 7.0 to indicate as much in that publication. Figure 29 in the 301 has an example of a PetersonCoil.
Points highlighted:
- Initial thoughts are a needed association from GroundDisconnector to the existing Ground class and, in turn, an association to the VoltageLevel called "Ground". We want to highlight the containment aspect of the modeling. This should then be included as an additional example in Figure 29.
Updated by Todd Viegut 2 months ago
- Subject changed from GroundDisconnector examplesThe intended use of GroundDisco to GroundDisconnector examples. The intended use of GroundDisconnector
Updated by Chavdar Ivanov 2 months ago
- Base Release set to CIM16
- Solution to be Applied To set to CIM18v13
- Solution Version set to CIM18v13
- Solution Applied By set to Chavdar Ivanov
- Breaking Change changed from No to Yes
- Breaking Change Description set to Modelling of Ground, GroundDisconnector is changed
- Decision updated (diff)
- Release Notes updated (diff)
- Originally Assigned To changed from Chavdar Ivanof to Chavdar Ivanov
Updated by Chavdar Ivanov 2 months ago
- Status changed from In Progress to Closed
- Completion Date set to 09/19/2024
- Release Notes updated (diff)