Issues #643
PICS mandates the support of Select and SelectWithValues for client even through PIXIT shows SBOns and SBOes can be N
Description
In the PICS version 2.3 and version 3.0, the S51 for Select and S52 SelectWithValue are mandatory in Client side.
At the same time, PIXIT template in client test procedure version 1.1.2 (Rev2) Ctl1, the four control modes are optional.
Does this mean that client has to implement Select even through SBOns is not supported, SelectWithValue even through SBOes is not supported?
Explain why Select and SelectWithValue are mandatory for clients. Otherwise update the PICS to make those two optional.
Files
| PICS_Controls.PNG | View PICS_Controls.PNG | 20.5 KB | PICS S51/S52 | ||
| PIXIT_Ctl1.PNG | View PIXIT_Ctl1.PNG | 61.7 KB | PIXIT Ctl1 |
Updated by Thierry Dufaure almost 4 years ago
All services associated to control (Select, SelectWithValue, Operate, Cancel) shall be supported by client. This is a pre-requisite for interoperability client server, as the control model used by an object is the decision of ther server configuration.
Updated by Richard Schimmel almost 4 years ago
- Final Decision set to PICS is correct, deprecate PIXIT Ctl1 for Ed2 and Amd1
- 61850 Edition Edition 2 Amd 1 added
TPWG: PIXIT entry Ctl1 shall be deprecated for Ed2 and Amd1.
Ctl1 1 ,2 What control modes are supported Y/N status-only
Y/N direct-with-normal-security
Y/N sbo-with-normal-security
Y/N direct-with-enhanced-security
Y/N sbo-with-enhanced-security
Updated by Joel Greene almost 4 years ago
- Status changed from New to Resolved
TPWG meeting 9 MAR 2021
Updated by Bruce Muschlitz over 2 years ago
- Status changed from Resolved to Closed
- Discuss in Upcoming Meeting changed from Yes to No
- Updated Test Document set to Server Ed2.0 TP2.0.6 and Server Ed2.1 TP1.2
- Closed Reason Test Procedure Update added